SDA and SIL conflict of interest explained
Why the NDIS encourages separating who provides your housing from who provides your support, and how to protect your choice and control
Why is combining SDA and SIL a conflict of interest?
It's a conflict because the same organisation controls two things that should be independent: your home and your support. If you're unhappy with your support workers, you might hesitate to complain or switch providers because the same organisation also controls your tenancy — and that pressure undermines your choice and control. Separation keeps the…
Is a combined provider always a problem?
No. Many good providers offer both and manage the conflict transparently — with separate agreements, clear complaints pathways, and a commitment that your tenancy is not tied to using their support. The key is that the conflict is disclosed and managed, not hidden. Under the NDIS Practice Standards, registered providers must identify and actively manage…
How do I protect my choice and control?
Sign separate agreements for your tenancy and your support.. Confirm in writing that your housing is not conditional on using their support.. Check the notice periods for support and tenancy are independent.. Know the complaints pathway, including the NDIS Commission.. Use an independent support coordinator to help you review options. If a provider won't…
Where can I get independent help?
An independent support coordinator, a disability advocate, or the NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission can help you understand and manage a conflict of interest. Because a support coordinator who is independent of your housing and support providers has no stake in your choices, they can advise freely. Our guide how-to-change-your-sil-provider explains your…
Where the conflict actually bites
The conflict of interest is easiest to understand through the moments where it changes your real choices. In each of these situations, the fact that one organisation controls both your home and your support quietly narrows your options. When a provider owns SDA homes and also delivers SIL, it has a financial reason to fill an empty room with its own support…
Questions to ask a combined provider
If one organisation offers you both housing and support, a few direct questions reveal quickly whether it manages the conflict well or glosses over it. Good providers welcome these; evasive answers are themselves an answer. Will my tenancy and my support be covered by separate, standalone agreements?. Can I change my support provider and keep living here?.…
Two agreements, two different jobs
The single most protective thing you can do is keep your housing and your support on separate agreements, because they do different jobs and should be able to end independently. Blurring them into one document is where control quietly slips away. If your provider only offers a single combined agreement, ask why, and get independent advice before you sign.
Raising concerns without risking your home
Many people put up with poor support because they fear that rocking the boat will cost them their housing. You are entitled to raise concerns, and there are safer ways to do it that keep your tenancy protected while you sort the support out. Put your concern in writing and keep a copy, so there is a clear record.. Ask an independent support coordinator or…
Frequently asked questions
What is an SDA/SIL conflict of interest?
It's the conflict that arises when the same organisation provides both your SDA housing and your SIL support. Because they influence both where you live and who supports you, it can be harder to change one without risking the other, which can undermine your choice and control.
Can the same provider do my SDA and SIL?
Yes, and many do, but they must disclose and actively manage the conflict of interest. Look for separate agreements, a clear commitment that your tenancy isn't tied to using their support, and an independent complaints pathway.
How do I protect my rights if one provider does both?
Sign separate agreements for housing and support, get written confirmation your tenancy isn't conditional on using their support, check the notice periods are independent, know the complaints process including the NDIS Commission, and use an independent support coordinator.
Does the NDIS require providers to manage conflicts of interest?
Yes. Under the NDIS Practice Standards, registered providers must identify and manage conflicts of interest and support participants' right to choice and control. You're entitled to ask a provider how they do this.
Can I lose my home if I change my SIL provider?
You shouldn't. Your housing and support should be governed by separate agreements so you can change your support provider without losing your home. If a provider implies otherwise, that's a red flag — seek advice from an independent support coordinator or advocate.
Why would a combined provider refer me to their own SDA home?
Because it has empty rooms to fill, a combined provider has a financial incentive to place its own support customers in its own housing. That is not automatically wrong, but it means a referral can be about their vacancy as much as your best fit, so it is worth getting an independent view before you accept.
Should my housing and support be on one agreement or two?
Two. A separate tenancy or SDA agreement and a separate service or SIL agreement let each one end independently, so you can change your support without risking your home. If a provider only offers a single combined agreement, ask why and seek independent advice before signing.
How do I complain about support without risking my housing?
Put your concern in writing, involve an independent support coordinator or advocate, and rely on your separate agreements to keep the tenancy out of the dispute. If you feel your home or safety is being used as leverage, contact the NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission straight away.