Novida logoNovida

Value for money in home and living decisions

What 'value for money' means in NDIS home-and-living decisions, why it's used to compare options, and how to make your preferred option stack up

What does value for money mean here?

Value for money means the support is a cost-effective way to meet your needs and pursue your goals, considering the benefits it delivers and the cost compared with other reasonable options. The NDIA weighs whether an equally effective option would cost less — not whether the cheapest option exists regardless of suitability. So a more expensive option can…

Why does the NDIS compare my options?

The NDIS compares options because it funds what's reasonable and necessary, and value for money is one of the criteria. For home and living, that often means weighing, say, solo SIL against shared support or an ILO, or SDA against home modifications — to check the funded option is justified. This is why evidence about why alternatives won't work is so…

How do I make my preferred option stack up?

Be clear about the outcomes your preferred option achieves.. Explain why cheaper or alternative options wouldn't meet your needs.. Provide evidence — OT, clinical, and lived experience.. Show the longer-term benefits (independence, reduced other supports).. Frame it as effective and justified, not just preferred. Making the value-for-money case explicitly,…

A worked example: comparing two options fairly

Value for money is easier to grasp with a concrete comparison, because it is about weighing cost against outcomes rather than picking a number. Imagine two ways of meeting the same need: a lower-cost shared support arrangement, and a higher-cost solo arrangement that better fits your situation. The point of laying it out this way is not that the pricier…

The evidence that proves value for money

The strongest value-for-money case is built on evidence that connects your preferred option to real outcomes, not just a statement that you prefer it. The NDIA is weighing whether the funding is justified, so the more clearly the evidence shows the option works and the alternatives wouldn't, the stronger your position. An occupational therapist (OT) report…

Common objections and how to answer them

When a value-for-money question comes up, it usually takes one of a few familiar forms, and having a considered answer ready makes a real difference. Each objection has a fair response grounded in the same principle: cost is weighed against outcomes for options that actually meet your needs. Answering calmly and with evidence, rather than simply restating a…

Value for money over the long term, not just this plan

Value for money isn't only about the cost of a support within a single plan — a support that builds your independence can lower your overall support needs over the years. The NDIA can consider these longer-term benefits, so it is worth making them visible rather than leaving them unsaid. For instance, an arrangement or a piece of assistive technology that…

Frequently asked questions

What does value for money mean in NDIS home and living?

It means a support is a cost-effective way to meet your needs and goals, considering the benefits it delivers against the cost compared with other reasonable options. It's part of the reasonable-and-necessary test, and it means cost-effective for the outcomes — not simply the cheapest option.

Does value for money mean the cheapest option?

No. It means the funding is justified by the outcomes, weighed against alternatives that would genuinely meet your needs. A more expensive option can still be value for money if cheaper alternatives wouldn't meet your needs or achieve the outcomes.

Why does the NDIS compare my housing options?

Because value for money is one of the reasonable-and-necessary criteria. For home and living, the NDIA often weighs options like solo SIL against shared support or an ILO, or SDA against home modifications, to check the funded option is justified for your needs.

How do I make the value-for-money case for my option?

Be clear about the outcomes it achieves, explain with evidence why cheaper or alternative options wouldn't meet your needs, show the longer-term benefits like independence or reduced other supports, and frame it as effective and justified rather than just preferred.

Can I get a more expensive option funded?

Yes, if it's justified. Value for money weighs cost against outcomes, so a higher-cost option can be funded where cheaper alternatives genuinely wouldn't meet your needs. Clear evidence of the outcomes and why alternatives fall short is what makes the case.

If a cheaper option exists, will the NDIS always fund that one?

Not automatically — value for money weighs cost against outcomes, so a cheaper option only wins if it would genuinely meet your needs and achieve the same outcomes. If a lower-cost arrangement would not actually work for you, it isn't a fair comparison, and clear evidence of why it falls short is what protects the…

How do I respond if I'm told to try shared support first?

Respond with evidence rather than just a preference — explain the specific risks or unmet needs that a shared arrangement would create for you, backed by OT or clinical evidence and, where relevant, what has been tried before. The value-for-money test compares options that genuinely meet your needs, so showing that…

Can longer-term savings count towards value for money?

Yes — the NDIA can consider longer-term benefits, so a support that builds independence and reduces future support needs, or prevents predictable crises, can be more cost-effective across a whole life even if it costs more now. Making that whole-of-life picture visible, rather than only the up-front cost, often…

Related guides

Browse NDIS housing vacancies on Novida