Do you need both SIL and SDA?
How SIL and SDA work together, when you'd have both, and why many people have one without the other
SIL is support; SDA is the building
The clearest way to hold these apart: SIL answers 'what help do I get?' and SDA answers 'do I need a specially designed home?'. SIL pays support workers for daily help. SDA pays a housing provider a contribution toward an accessible, robust or high-support dwelling. Because they answer different questions, they're assessed on different evidence and funded…
When do you have both SIL and SDA?
You'd typically have both when you need a high level of daily support (SIL) *and* your disability means an ordinary home won't work — you need reinforced walls, ceiling hoists, full wheelchair access or a specialist build (SDA). People with very high physical support needs often have both, delivered as two separate lines in the plan by two providers. Having…
When is one enough?
SIL without SDA — you need significant daily support but can live in an ordinary rental or your own home. This is the most common combination.. SDA without SIL — you need a specialist building but arrange your support differently (for example drop-in support, family support, or ILO).. Neither — you need some support at home, funded through your Core budget…
How the two providers work together
When you have both, your SDA provider owns and manages the dwelling and receives the SDA payment plus your Reasonable Rent Contribution. Your SIL provider delivers the daily support and is paid from Core. They can be — and often are — different companies, which protects your choice: you can change your support provider without moving house. Ask: 'Is what I…
A step-by-step way to work out what you need
You can reason your way to an answer by asking two separate questions in order: do I need a specially designed building, and how much daily support do I need? The answers point to SDA, SIL, both, or neither — and they rarely point to both. Ask whether an ordinary home — with home modifications if needed — could safely work for you. If yes, you probably do…
SIL and SDA are proven with different evidence
Because they answer different questions, SIL and SDA are assessed on very different evidence, and strong evidence for one does not carry over to the other. Preparing the right evidence for each is what gets them approved. SDA in particular has a high bar — it is only for a small proportion of participants whose needs cannot be met with ordinary housing plus…
Which comes first, and how long it takes
There is no fixed order, but in practice the two often move on different timelines, and it helps to start the slower one early. SDA decisions can take a long time because they rest on detailed OT and medical evidence and are approved for relatively few people. SIL is quoted from a Roster of Care and tends to be resolved within a plan reassessment cycle. If…
If you have both: two agreements and the conflict-of-interest rule
When you are funded for both, you will usually sign two separate agreements — an SDA residency or tenancy agreement with your housing provider, and a SIL service agreement with your support provider. Your SDA provider receives the dwelling payment plus your Reasonable Rent Contribution; your SIL provider is paid from Core for the support. Keeping the two…
Frequently asked questions
Do you need both SIL and SDA?
Not usually. SIL funds daily support and SDA is a contribution toward a specialist building. Many people need only SIL (support in an ordinary home). You'd have both when you need a high level of daily support and a specially designed dwelling.
Can you have SDA without SIL?
Yes. SDA and SIL are assessed separately. You can be eligible for a specialist dwelling (SDA) while arranging your support another way — drop-in support, family support or an Individualised Living Option (ILO).
Can you have SIL without SDA?
Yes, and it's the most common combination. Many people receive significant daily support (SIL) while living in an ordinary rental or their own home, with no specialist dwelling funding.
Are SIL and SDA paid to the same provider?
Not necessarily. SDA is paid to the housing provider that owns the dwelling; SIL is paid to your support provider. They're often different companies, which means you can change your support provider without having to move house.
How do I know which I need?
Ask whether your need is about the task or the building. Help with showering, cooking or getting to bed points to SIL support; needing an accessible or reinforced building points to SDA. Most people need SIL only.
Is it harder to get SDA than SIL?
Generally yes. SDA has a high threshold — extreme functional impairment or very high support needs — and is funded for only a small share of participants, backed by detailed OT and medical evidence. SIL is more common and is worked out from a Roster of Care, so many people are funded for SIL without ever qualifying for…
Can the same company provide my SDA and my SIL?
It can, but it creates a recognised conflict of interest that the provider must disclose and manage. Keeping your housing and support with separate organisations is safer for your choice and control, because it means you can change support providers without having to move out of your home.
Do I need SDA if my home just needs modifications?
Usually not. If home modifications — a ramp, an accessible bathroom, a ceiling hoist — can make an ordinary home safe and workable, that is often funded instead of SDA. SDA is reserved for people who need a purpose-built or specially reinforced dwelling that modifications alone cannot achieve.