Novida logoNovida

Common Reasons the NDIS Says No

Common reasons the NDIS says no — not reasonable and necessary, another system's responsibility, not enough evidence — and how to respond to each.

When the NDIS says no, the letter can feel blunt and confusing. But most refusals come down to a handful of recurring reasons — and once you understand which one applies to you, you know exactly what to do about it. This guide walks through the most common reasons, in plain language, and gives you a practical way to respond to each.

Why understanding the reason matters

A no from the NDIS almost always comes with a reason, even if it's buried in formal language. Finding and understanding that reason is the single most useful thing you can do, because your response should answer the specific concern raised — not appeal in general. The good news is that most refusals fall into a few familiar categories, and each has a fairly…

Not reasonable and necessary

The NDIS funds supports that are 'reasonable and necessary' and related to your disability. A very common reason for a no is that a support didn't clearly meet that test — or wasn't shown to. How to respond: make the case plainly. Show how the support relates to your disability, how it helps you pursue your goals and take part in daily life, and why it…

Another system's responsibility

A frequent refusal reason is that a support is 'another system's responsibility' — that it should come from health, education, housing or another mainstream service rather than the NDIS. How to respond: show why the support is disability-related and part of building your capacity and participation, rather than something the other system ordinarily provides.…

Not enough evidence

Perhaps the most common reason of all is simply that there wasn't enough evidence to support the request. The need may be real, but if it wasn't clearly shown, the decision-maker can't act on it. How to respond: this is the most fixable reason of all. Add up-to-date reports, functional evidence about your daily life, and specific examples. Recent reports…

Not related to your disability, or better value elsewhere

Two other reasons come up regularly. One is that a support was seen as not sufficiently related to your disability — more of a general life cost that most people have. The other is that there's a more suitable or better-value way to meet the need. How to respond: for the first, draw a clear line from the support to your disability and its effects. For the…

Turning a no into a next step

Whatever reason you were given, the path forward is the same: understand it, then respond to it with evidence, through an internal review and, if needed, the Tribunal. Identify the exact reason in your decision letter.. Gather evidence that answers that reason directly.. Request an internal review within the timeframe.. Get free help from an advocate or…

Frequently asked questions

Why did the NDIS say no?

Most refusals come down to a few reasons: a support wasn't shown to be reasonable and necessary, it was seen as another system's responsibility, there wasn't enough evidence, or it wasn't sufficiently related to your disability. Your decision letter should state the reason — read it closely.

What does 'not reasonable and necessary' mean?

It means the support didn't clearly meet the NDIS funding test — or wasn't shown to. To respond, show how the support relates to your disability, helps you pursue your goals and take part in daily life, and represents reasonable value, using concrete examples and up-to-date reports.

What does 'another system's responsibility' mean?

It means the NDIA considers the support should come from health, education, housing or another mainstream service rather than the NDIS. It's not a dead end — clear evidence that the need is disability-related and about building your capacity can change how it's viewed.

The NDIS says there wasn't enough evidence — what now?

This is the most fixable reason. Add up-to-date reports from professionals who know you, functional evidence about how your disability affects daily life, and specific real-life examples. Our guide Evidence for an NDIS appeal shows how to assemble a strong case.

How do I respond to a refusal?

Identify the exact reason in your decision letter, gather evidence that answers it directly, request an internal review within the timeframe, and get free help from an advocate or legal aid. A no is often a request for more information, not a final word.

Can I challenge more than one reason at once?

Yes. A decision may raise several points, and your response can address each one — showing the support is disability-related, reasonable and necessary, and backed by evidence. Working through them point by point, with an advocate's help, is a sound approach.

Related guides

Find NDIS providers near you on Novida