Novida logoNovida

SIL vs Group Home: What's the Difference?

SIL vs group home explained: why SIL is support not a house, how modern shared living differs from legacy group homes, and how to get more choice.

People often use 'SIL' and 'group home' as if they mean the same thing, and that confusion can steer you toward a home with less choice than you're entitled to. In truth, one is a type of funding and the other is a type of living arrangement. This guide untangles SIL vs group home, so you can understand what you're really choosing and ask for the control you deserve.

The core difference in one line

Here's the distinction that clears up most of the confusion: Supported Independent Living (SIL) is the support that comes into a home. A group home is a type of home. They're not opposites — you can receive SIL funding while living in a group home — but they answer different questions. SIL answers 'who helps me, and how much?' A group home answers 'what kind…

What SIL is

SIL is NDIS funding for the support you need to live in your own home when you need help most or all of the time — help with daily tasks, personal care, supervision and building skills. It's funded from your Core budget and built around a roster of care describing who supports you, when, and for how long. Crucially, SIL is about the support, not the walls.…

What a group home is

A 'group home' is a shared living arrangement where several people with disability live together and receive shared support. Many are older 'legacy' dwellings, and some house six or more residents. The Disability Royal Commission was critical of the traditional group home model — not because sharing is wrong, but because it too often meant people had little…

SIL vs group home, side by side

It helps to see them lined up: What it is — SIL is funding for support; a group home is a shared dwelling.. Choice of housemates — with SIL you can seek out compatible housemates; traditional group homes often placed people together by vacancy.. Choice of provider — SIL lets you choose (and change) your support provider; in some group homes support and…

Where they overlap

This is where the terms blur. Someone living in a shared SIL home with two or three housemates might reasonably call it a 'group home' in everyday speech, and that's fine. The difference that matters isn't the label — it's the degree of choice and control built in. A shared home where compatible people genuinely chose to live together, with support they…

Getting more choice, whichever you're in

Whether you're exploring a brand-new arrangement or already in a shared home, you can push for more control: Choose your housemates where you can — ask how matching is done and whether you can meet people first.. Separate housing from support — remember you can change your SIL provider without moving house.. Insist on a real roster of care built around your…

Which is right for you?

There's no universally 'better' answer — some people thrive in a well-matched shared home, while others want to live alone or with a partner and bring support in. What matters is that the arrangement reflects your choices, not just what's available. If you're weighing options, read the companion guides on what SIL funding covers, how to choose a SIL…

Frequently asked questions

Is SIL the same as a group home?

No. SIL is NDIS funding for the support that comes into a home; a group home is a type of shared dwelling. You can receive SIL while living in a group home, but you can also receive SIL living alone or with housemates you choose. They're separate decisions.

Can I get SIL without living in a group home?

Yes. SIL funds support, not a specific house. You can receive SIL living on your own, with a partner, or in a small shared home you choose. You're not required to live in a traditional group home to access supported independent living funding.

Why are legacy group homes criticised?

The Disability Royal Commission found traditional group homes too often gave residents little say over who they lived with, who supported them, or how their day ran. The concern is loss of choice and control — the institutional culture — rather than shared living itself.

Can I change my support without moving house?

Yes, where housing and support are separate. Because SIL funds the support, not the dwelling, you can usually change your SIL provider while staying in the same home. If your housing and support are bundled by one provider, ask your support coordinator how to separate them.

Related guides

Find NDIS providers near you on Novida